The Villainization of GTA 6: How Video Games Remain a Convenient Political Distraction

Advertisements

Editor’s Note: The following is a follow-up to an opinion piece I wrote in 2019, addressing the previous wave of claims by American lawmakers that violent video games and mental illness were primary drivers of violence.

In 2019, in the wake of the mass shootings in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, I wrote about a deeply ingrained habit in American politics. Instead of addressing what actually turns grievance into violence—unchecked access to high-capacity weapons, warning signs of prior violence, and toxic, hate-driven ideologies—politicians turned to a convenient scapegoat: violent video games. Time and again, both lawmakers and news media lean on this tired trope to capitalize on public fear and evade accountability for years of inaction.

Over the years, that pattern has carried on and escalated into widespread book bans and media censorship. A recent report from PEN America revealed nearly 12,000 instances of book bans in public schools during the 2025–2026 school year—the highest number recorded in a single year since the organization began tracking the issue. Now, lawmakers are using the launch of Rockstar Games’ Grand Theft Auto VI not only to blame video games for violence, but to suggest that parents who let their kids play are simply failing at their responsibilities. Representative Tim Burchett of Tennessee described the game as a ‘how-to video’ for crime, claimed it ‘desensitizes kids,’ and asserted that ‘study after study’ supports the concern. Yet these claims are nothing new—and they are not supported by the weight of scientific evidence.

Even inside Congress, that form of logic falls apart under scrutiny. Representative Maxwell Frost of Florida dismissed Burchett’s concern, calling it overblown and pointing out the obvious flaw in blaming Rockstar’s franchise: ‘There’s GTA V in a lot of countries, but we’re the only country where the leading cause of death is to be shot for a child.’ Decades of psychological research back that reality up. Looking at the facts, the American Psychological Association and multiple large-scale reviews have found no reliable link between violent video games and real-world violence, including mass shootings. While laboratory studies have occasionally detected small, short-term increases in aggressive thoughts or mild irritability, those effects do not translate into criminal violence. Long-term research tracking young people over the years has repeatedly shown that any association between game content and later aggression becomes negligible once other factors are controlled. Countries with high rates of violent game consumption simply do not experience the levels of gun violence seen in the United States—and youth violence in the U.S. actually declined substantially during the exact decades in which games like Grand Theft Auto became mainstream.

Advertisements
Advertisements
Far from sparking the wave of real-world crime critics warned about, Grand Theft Auto has become a mainstream cultural phenomenon—with GTA V selling more than 230 million copies worldwide as a sharp satire of American life, as a recent PBS NewsHour report highlights.

Historical records are just as consistent as the science. For more than 70 years, politicians and moral crusaders have raised the same alarm over whatever was popular with youth culture at the time. In the 1950s, congressional hearings blamed comic books for juvenile delinquency. In the 1980s, lawmakers targeted heavy metal lyrics. Ten years later, Mortal Kombat and Doom were painted as murder simulators, and fast-forward to the 2000s and beyond, many of those same anxieties have been aimed at anime, manga, and graphic novels. Every single time, critics warned of an imminent wave of copycat violence—and every single time, that wave failed to materialize at the scale they claimed.

What stands out above all of this is not merely the weakness of evidence, but it is the selectivity of the attention. The same political voices that treat a mature-rated video game as a urgent cultural threat have, in other contexts, responded to actual school shootings (or shootings in public areas) with notable resignation. For example, after the 2023 Covenant School shooting in his home state, Representative Burchett stated that “We’re not gonna fix it,” observed that criminals will be criminals, and emphasized cultural and spiritual renewal over legislative urgency. Similarly, in recent years, controversial uses of force during immigration enforcement operations—including fatal shootings and physical confrontations involving bystanders—have generated significant public concern and cost real lives, yet they have rarely triggered the same immediate level of moral alarm directed at a video game. When real human lives are met with resignation while virtual crime sparks outrage, it becomes clear that the panic isn’t about protecting people.
Advertisements
Advertisements

Keep in mind that video games are not above criticism, or that parents should ignore age ratings. Grand Theft Auto VI is rated Mature 17+ for clear reasons. The real issue is one of proportion and consistency. When officials devote more rhetorical energy to a commercial entertainment product than to the more predictive and difficult drivers of real violence, the effect is to narrow the conversation rather than clarify it.

The research has been available for years. As you can see, the historical pattern is well-documented; however, the selective focus remains. Treating video games as a primary explanation for violence continues to offer a simpler target than the harder problems that actually produce it.

Real-world violence isn’t born in Vice City—it is fueled by unchecked access to high-capacity weapons, ignored warning signs of prior violence, and toxic, hate-driven ideologies. Politicians and news media know it is easier to blame mental illness after a tragedy or attack popular games such as Grand Theft Auto VI during its launch week than it is to pass meaningful safeguards or fund mental health care. Gamers, readers, and everyday citizens deserve better than another round of moral panic. Until elected officials stop hiding behind convenient scapegoats and confront what actually puts lives in danger, nothing is going to change.

Want to experience Leonida for yourself?
Grand Theft Auto VI is available now for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. You can pick up a copy through Amazon at the links below.

Thanks for reading! If you have any suggestions, news tips, or questions, email them to: webmaster@bigrednerd.com.

Follow Me on Social Media!

This post contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links and make a purchase, we’ll receive a percentage of the sale. Whatever purchase through the affiliate links helps the site.

Ko-Fi Support Badge
Thanks for checking out my writing and art! If you’d like to support my work, you can leave a tip here.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.